Looking for a clean, organic protein powder can be time consuming and difficult to judge. That is why we put together this list of the 6 best organic protein powders. We compiled this list based on benefits, quality, price, and customer reviews. At Naturally Good Living, we believe in pure, natural ingredients and understand the importance of brand transparency. We believe that you will fall in love with each of these brands and their organic protein powders, just as we have!
Table of Contents
Related: Whey vs Plant Protein, High Protein Cottage Cheese Eggs, 24 High Protein Foods
Medical Disclaimer: This article is intended for educational and informational purposes only. It is not intended as a substitute for medical advice. For medical and health advice, consult with a licensed healthcare professional.
Why choose organic protein powder?
Many people struggle with choosing organic alternatives simply because of the price. Which is entirely understandable! You want to try and find that one cheap product that will give you all the benefits of the more pricey one. However, that way of thinking a lot of the times is just not realistic. In the end, “you get what you pay for!” Cheap “quick fixes” and shortcuts will give you cheap and short lasting benefits.
Most of the time you end up wasting more money on the cheap product because you do not find what you are looking for and end up throwing it away or never using it. Alternatively, purchasing a product that you know will give you the results you are looking for and will use again and again is worth the investment!
We understand that budget is super important and that is why we have included organic protein powders that vary in price range. We also took into account wether or not the company offers money back guarantees, so that you can be sure you love it before committing to it!
So, what does organic protein powder have to offer? When you choose organic, you are choosing quality, safe products that will maximize the nutrient benefits you receive. In other words, you get all the “good stuff” (protein and nutrients) without the “bad stuff” (heavy metals, pesticides, and other harmful substances).
Most brands of protein powder contain heavy metals such as arsenic, lead, mercury, and cadmium. All of which can cause severe health issues. According to the National Library of Medicine, heavy metal impacts on human health can include cancers, dermatitis, muscular impairments, reproductive system damage, low infant birth rate, lactations problems, gastrointestinal diseases, lungs diseases, kidney diseases, immune disfunction, and nervous system disfunction.
With a long list of health issues like this one, it is understandable why so many people are switching to organic products that test and ensure their products do not contain dangerous levels of heavy metals.
Along with heavy metals, many protein powders on the market are full of pesticides, herbicides, allergens, toxins, and many other harmful substances. Protein powder is meant to be beneficial to you, not damaging! That is why when you buy organic, you are putting your health first by ensuring you don’t get all the “nasty stuff” that many companies don’t test for!
When searching for good-quality, organic protein powders, look for brands who have their products third party tested for heavy metals and other harmful substances. This will help you ensure the safety of a product and the quality of service that particular brand provides. The following list of the 6 best organic protein powders includes wether or not each product is third party tested and approved, so that you can know you are buying the best and safest option for your health!
Wondering which kind of protein source is best for you? Read our article on whey vs plant protein to learn more on the benefits and downsides of each of these commonly found protein sources in organic protein powder.
What is the best organic protein powder?
Our health is one of the most important investments we can make. That is why it is important to choose the best organic protein powder for your own goals. Choosing the right organic protein powder for you can make the biggest difference in your fitness and health journey. That is why we took the time to carefully analyze the following organic protein powders to make the decision easier for you.
We took into consideration different dietary choices like Paleo and Vegan diets. As well as dietary allergens such as milk and gluten. We also understand the importance of budget and have included good-quality products in a varying price range.
Each of the following 6 best organic protein powders will be judged based on benefits, quality, price, and customer reviews to make sure you have all the facts before buying.
Lastly, it is essential to know that each of these organic protein powders are not meant to replace a healthy lifestyle. In order to achieve your health goals it is important to have a balanced life with a good diet, hydration, exercise, and proper rest. Protein powders are meant to aid you in your health journey with plenty of protein and nutrients, not serve as a replacement for good health practices.
1. Best Bone Broth Organic Protein Powder: Paleovalley 100% Grass Fed Bone Broth Protein
Paleovalley’s 100% Grass Fed Bone Broth Protein gives you all the benefits of traditional bone broth without the hassle of making it yourself. Its greatest feature is its simple ingredients: filtered water and 100% grass fed and finished beef bones. That’s it! For more information see our full Paleovalley Bone Broth Protein Review.
Benefits
Bone broth is packed with collagen. According to Cleveland Clinic, collagen is 30% of your body’s protein make-up. It is responsible for providing structure, fortifies your skin, muscles, bones, and connective tissue.
So, not only will you be getting 13g of protein per serving, you will also receive the benefits of collagen which includes, boosting metabolism, supporting healthy hair and nail growth, reducing cellulite, improving digestion, supporting gut and joint health, supporting lowered risk of heart disease, and more.
Quality
Paleovalley is committed to quality. They test their products in third party labs for both pesticides and herbicides.
Their 100% Grass Fed Bone Broth Protein comes from cows who are fed only grass that is free from pesticides all year round. Their cows are never given any hormones, steroids, or antibiotics.
It is minimally processed. Created traditionally, simmering bones to extract the nutrients into the broth. It is then dried and packaged. That’s it!
Price
The regular price is $59.99 each plus shipping.
Shipping is free if three or more bags are ordered at once. Additionally, you can save 10% (priced $53.99).
They have a subscription option to save 20% (priced $47.99) for the first and each automated monthly order of 100% Grass Fed Bone Broth Protein.
They offer a 60 day money back guarantee.
Customer Reviews
Based on 3,589 customer reviews they have received a rating of 4.9 stars.
The lowest rated reviews, although very few, were mostly complaints on taste. Some say it was too sweet, while some said it was not strong enough. It all comes down to personal preference. The bright side is Paleovalley offers a 60 day money back guarantee, so you can try out the flavor for yourself at no risk!
The highest rated reviews were all positive comments on taste, texture, customer service, and healthy hair results. The customers say the taste is “amazing” and “can easily be hidden” in a drink. According to the reviews, the texture is “smooth” and blends well. The customers appreciate that Paleovalley is family-owned and has “excellent” customer service. Some comments were left saying that their hair is noticeably thicker.
Final Thoughts
Paleovalley’s 100% Grass Fed Bone Broth Protein is a great choice for someone looking for the benefits of both a good quality source of protein and collagen without the risks of growth hormones, steroids, antibiotics, pesticides, and herbicides.
They are decently priced at $59.99 each, plus shipping, for the quality of product you will receive. They offer 20% off subscription benefits, and when ordering three or more you will earn 10% off plus free shipping.
Their customers speak positively about the taste, texture, customer service, and healthy hair results. Some customers complained of the taste, but Paleovalley offers a 60 day money back guarantee, so you can try the taste out for yourself with no risk!
See our full in-depth Paleovalley Bone Broth Protein Review.
2. Best Meal Replacement Organic Protein Powder: Ka’Chava Tribal Superfood
Ka’Chava Tribal Superfood is made with over 85 “superfoods”, is plant-based, and vegan friendly. Ka’Chava is an excellent choice of organic protein powder because its formulated not only with protein but also with fiber, antioxidants, adaptogens, super-greens, probiotics/prebiotics, and digestive enzymes to maximize the nutrient benefits. See our full Ka’Chava Superfood Review.
Benefits
The benefit of using Ka’Chava Tribal Superfood is that it not only supports the body, but the mind as well.
Supports immunity by providing nutrients such as Zinc, Selenium, Vitamins B6, B12, A, C, and D.
Provides an energy boost with complex carbohydrates, protein, B-complex vitamins, iron, vitamin C, phosphorous, and magnesium.
Supports the mind’s tolerance to stress through adaptogens. Adaptogens have been used throughout history for centuries to support the mind. Cleveland Clinic defines an adaptogen as “a group of plants and herbs that can reduce stress.”
Supports healthy digestion with fiber, probiotics, vitamin D, digestive enzymes, and zinc.
Supports muscle growth by combining protein and 26 vitamins and minerals that support muscle growth and health.
Aids in healthy weight loss by filling you up with protein and fiber while still being calorie controlled.
Supports cardiovascular system health with fiber, omega-3 fatty acids, magnesium, calcium, potassium, and folate.
Supports healthy joints and bones with calcium, magnesium, vitamins D, C, and phosphorous.
Supports healthy skin with protein, Zinc, vitamins A, E, C, and B-complex.
Quality
Ka’Chava Tribal Superfood certifications include: USDA Organic, cGMP Certified, and TGA Certified.
Their ingredients are consciously sourced from small farmers around the world who practice sustainability.
Their ingredients are tested both by them and third party labs for ingredient ID, allergens, heavy metals, toxins, aflatoxins, pesticides, organoleptic, potency, purity, and microbial.
The finished product is tested both by them and third party labs for supplement fact verification, microbial, allergens, heavy metals, and organoleptic.
Price
Ka’Chava Tribal Superfood is regularly priced at $69.95 plus shipping.
They offer a subscribe and save $10 per bag (priced $59.95) for initial and each recurring, automated monthly order.
They include a 30 day money back guarantee.
Customer Reviews
On their website they received a 4.6 star rating based on 71,132 reviews.
Their lowest rated reviews were comments on flavor and delayed shipping. Most of them said they simply do not like the taste. There were very few comments that mentioned they never received their package and that they were disappointed they do not ship to Canada. Fortunately, Ka’Chava offers a 30 day money back guarantee, so you can try it out for yourself at no risk!
Their highest rated reviews commented positively on the taste, thickness, and nutritious benefits. Many customers say the shakes were very filling and left them feeling energized. They also say they loved the taste.
Final Thoughts
Ka’Chava Tribal Superfood is a great healthy swap for someone looking for a plant-based, low calorie, but filling and nutritious meal replacement organic protein powder.
This vegan friendly organic protein powder offer benefits such as supporting the immune, digestive, and cardiovascular systems, healthy skin, joints, bones, muscle growth, weight loss, and stress tolerance. Combined with quality control from third party lab testing and certifications from USDA Organic, cGMP, and TGA makes this product worth purchasing at $69.95.
Their lowest ratings were based on taste and delayed shipping, but their highest ratings outweighed them in number and were based positively on taste, thickness, and nutritious benefits.
You can try Ka’Chava Tribal Superfood without risk with a 30 day money back guarantee.
See our full in-depth Ka’Chava Superfood Review.
3. Best Whey Organic Protein Powder: Raw Organic Whey
Raw Organic Whey offers the benefits of whey protein while being sustainably sourced and free of any heavy metals, pesticides, hormones, antibiotics, GMO’s, and mycotoxins. This organic protein powder is high in protein and made with only one ingredient!
Benefits
Raw Organic Whey offers a clean source of protein that includes all the essential amino acids our bodies need. Essential amino acids cannot be produced in the body, and can only be obtained through dietary means, mainly through protein consumption. They are used for building muscle and immune system regulation.
Whey protein can support the immune system, provide energy, promote healthy metabolic rate, increase lean muscle mass while decreasing body fat percentage, support glutathione production, support healthy joints, and support beneficial bacteria growth in the gut.
Quality
Raw Organic Whey is made from grass fed and pasture raised cows’s milk. There is no added sweeteners, preservatives, fillers, or soy lecithin.
It is certified USDA Organic, GMO free, and soy free.
It is sustainably sourced from small farms, free of any acid treatments, and processed at low temperatures.
The product is third party lab tested for heavy metals, antibiotics, pesticides, mycotoxins, and melamine. Their test results are provided on their website.
The packaging is BPA free.
Price
Raw Organic Whey is regularly priced at $119.99 plus shipping.
It is also sold on Amazon.
They offer a smaller size for less: 12oz Bag for $34.99.
Customer Reviews
Raw Organic Whey has a 5 star rating based on 472 customer reviews.
The lowest rated reviews mentioned both high price and difficulty sealing the bag closed.
The highest rated reviews mention how they love the creamy taste and how well it blends into smoothies. Many say that the price is worth the quality product you receive. Lots of customers appreciate that it is made with just one ingredient and no extra stuff.
Final Thoughts
While Raw Organic Whey is pricey at $119.99, if you are looking for a quality clean protein powder, the price is worth it in the end. This organic protein powder is a great choice for someone looking for high protein content, lean muscle mass and workout recovery.
Whey protein provides essential amino acids and supports the immune system, boosts energy, promotes healthy metabolic rate, increases lean muscle mass while decreasing body fat percentage, supports glutathione production, joint health, and beneficial bacteria in the gut.
Some customers do not appreciate the high price and the difficult bag seal. Many customers appreciate the quality and taste of Raw Organic Whey.
The quality, taste, creaminess, and benefits that Raw Organic Whey offers makes the purchase worthwhile. It is also sold in a smaller size for less, so that you can try it out without spending $119 on your first purchase.
4. Best Versatile Organic Protein Powder: Just Ingredients Just Plain Protein Powder
Just Ingredient’s Just Plain Protein Powder is made with 4 different sources of protein: 100% grass fed non-denatured whey protein, organic pea protein, collagen protein, and chia seed protein. All of which comes with their own benefits! This organic protein powder is made to be used in many of your favorite recipes such as baked goods, smoothies, and more for an extra boost of protein.
Benefits
Both whey protein and pea protein provide many amino acids. Essential amino acids cannot be produced in the body, and can only be obtained through dietary means, mainly through protein consumption. They are used for building muscle and immune system regulation.
Collagen supports many structures of the body. According to Cleveland Clinic, collagen is 30% of your body’s protein make-up. It is responsible for providing structure, fortifies your skin, muscles, bones, and connective tissue.
Chia seed protein is considered a complete protein. This means that it provides all 9 essential amino acids your body needs for healthy muscles. It also provides fiber and omega-3 fatty acids for healthy brain and gut support.
Quality
Just Ingredients tests their Just Plain Protein Powder for heavy metals, microbial, and gluten. They have their test result certification posted on their website for customers to view.
The ingredients are 100% natural. It does not contain any artificial flavorings, dyes, or sweeteners.
Price
It is regularly priced at $59.99 plus shipping.
They offer a subscribe and save 10% option (priced $53.99) for initial and recurring, automatic monthly purchases.
They offer a 30 day money back guarantee.
Customer Reviews
Based on 62 reviews they have received a 4.9 star rating.
Their lowest rated reviews are comments on how sweet the flavor is. The Just Plain Protein Powder is sweetened with stevia leaf and monk fruit. Some customers do not like how the stevia tastes. So, as long as you do not mind the taste of stevia, this is still a good option for you.
Their highest rated reviews comment positively how versatile it is and how it is naturally sweet. The customers love how they can use it in almost any recipe including pancakes, waffles, muffins, smoothies and more. Many have said that they enjoy the naturally sweet taste.
Final Thoughts
Just Ingredients Just Plain Protein Powder is a great versatile organic protein powder option for someone who is looking to add extra protein in their own unique recipes, and not just shakes.
Its 4 different protein sources offer many benefits including amino acids, collagen, fiber, and omega-3 fatty acids.
It 100% natural and tested for heavy metals, microbial, and gluten.
Some customers do not like the taste of stevia and say it is too sweet. While many customers love the sweet taste and the endless baking options.
It is decently priced at $59.99 plus shipping and Just Ingredients offers a 30 day money back guarantee.
5. Best Allergen Friendly Organic Protein Powder: Ora Organic So Lean & So Clean Plant-Based Superfood Protein
Ora Organic So Lean & So Clean Plant-Based Superfood Protein is made with vegan friendly plant based protein and 19 plant-based superfoods. This organic protein powder has no added sugar and is made with clean ingredients so that it does not leave you feeling bloated. It is free of dairy, wheat, gluten, eggs, peanuts, soy, fish, shellfish, artificial flavors or colors, pesticides, herbicides, and parabens.
Benefits
The plant-based proteins provide essential and non essential amino acids. Essential amino acids cannot be produced in the body, and can only be obtained through dietary means, mainly through protein consumption. They are used for building muscle and immune system regulation.
The 19 plant-based superfoods provide antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals. They provide easy digestion, support the cardiovascular system and the mind.
Quality
Ora Organic has their products third party tested for heavy metals, ingredient potency, microbial, and pathogens.
They annually screen each of their products for allergens, pesticides, and supplement fact verification.
Each product’s test results are posted on their website for customers to view.
Price
The So Lean & So Clean Plant-Based Superfood Protein is regularly priced at $39.99 plus shipping.
They offer a subscribe and save 20% (priced $31.99) for initial and recurring, automatic monthly purchases.
They offer a 60 day money back guarantee on all first time purchases.
Customer Reviews
Based on 2,730 reviews they have received a 4.5 star rating.
Their lowest rated reviews were comments on taste and texture. Some customers say that they do not like the flavor of the product. Some have also said that it is difficult to mix and is somewhat chalky. The bright side is Ora Organic offers a 60 day money back guarantee for all first time purchases. They also have a wide range of flavors to choose from.
Their highest rated reviews spoke positively on the taste, texture, and how light they feel after using it. Many customers love the taste and say that it is not too smooth and not too grainy. They love how it can be used just plain in milk or water, and in many other ways. Many customers say that it does not make them feel bloated after eating.
Final Thoughts
Ora Organic So Lean & So Clean Plant-Based Superfood Protein is a great vegan, dairy and gluten free option for someone looking to have an extra boost of protein without feeling bloated.
This product is third party tested for heavy metals, ingredient potency, microbial, and pathogens. It is also screened annually for allergens, pesticides, and supplement fact verification.
It is priced regularly at $39.99 plus shipping. They offer a subscribe and save 20% (priced $31.99) option for initial and automated recurring purchases.
Some customers do not like the taste or texture. While many tend to love the taste and the balance between smooth and gritty texture. They offer many different flavor options, so anyone can find the taste they are looking for.
Ora Organic offers a clean organic protein powder at an affordable price. It is allergen friendly and packed with nutritious plant-based superfoods. You can try Ora Organic So Lean & So Clean Plant-Based Superfood Protein at no risk with a 60 day money back guarantee for all first time purchases.
6. Best Flavored Whey Organic Protein Powder: NorCal Organic Whey Protein
NorCal Organic Whey Protein offers both flavored and unflavored whey without compromising the quality of the whey and other ingredients. This organic protein powder is free of added sugars, flavors, or colors and is not acid washed or bleached. However, the unflavored whey and flavored whey does contain a small amount of sunflower lecithin to make it more easily mixable. If sunflower lecithin is bothersome to you, NorCal offers a classic option that is unflavored and contains no sunflower lecithin.
Benefits
The non-denatured whey protein offers the benefits of immunoglobins, lactoferrin, and native growth factors. It is also a great source of branch chain amino acids. According to WebMD, branch chain amino acids are proteins that are used in the body for energy. They may also help prevent your muscles from breaking down while exercising.
Quality
NorCal uses organic grass fed cow’s milk to produce their whey. It is free of added sugars, flavors, or colors and is not acid washed or bleached.
Their cows are pasture raised and treated humanely. They are certified by the American Humane Association.
NorCal Organic Whey Protein is USDA Organic certified and certified by Non-GMO Project.
It is third party tested for heavy metals, allergens, bleach, and pesticides. The test results are posted on their website for customers to view.
Price
It is regularly priced at $64 plus shipping.
They offer a subscribe and save 15% (priced $54.40) for initial and each recurring, automated purchases.
They offer a 30 day money back guarantee.
Customer Reviews
Based on 101 reviews, NorCal Organic Whey Protein has received a rating of 4.84 stars.
Their lowest reviews are comments on price. Some customers do not appreciate the high price. They do offer a 30 day money back guarantee if you decide it is not for you.
Their highest reviews are positive comments on taste and quality. Many customers say they love the taste and appreciate it is all natural with no added sugars. They also love the quality of the whey protein and how easily it mixes into drinks.
Final Thoughts
NorCal Organic Whey Protein is perfect for someone looking for a clean, naturally flavored whey protein. It is sold as unflavored whey, classic whey (no sunflower lecithin), chocolate, and vanilla.
This organic protein powder offers benefits of immunoglobins, lactoferrin, native growth factors, and branch chain amino acids for muscle support.
It is priced at $64 plus shipping regularly. You can subscribe and save 15% (priced $54.40) for initial and automated recurring purchases.
Some customers do not appreciate the high price. While many customers say they love the taste and quality NorCal has to offer.
NorCal provides excellent quality whey protein at a decent price with flavored and unflavored options. Its nutritious benefits make it a worthwhile purchase. You can try NorCal Organic Whey Protein at no risk with a 30 day money back guarantee.
Want to learn more about whey protein? Find more information on whey protein and its alternatives here.
Conclusion
When it comes to organic protein powders, it is important to choose the best quality product that matches your health goals. Each of these 6 organic protein powders come with their own benefits and drawbacks. We have judged them based on benefits, quality, price, and customer reviews to help give you the information you need to make the right choice for you. Any of these products will make for an excellent choice and provide you with the extra protein and nutrients you have been searching for!
Alway remember that nothing can replace good health habits, not even these organic protein powders. A healthy, balanced lifestyle full of exercise, good diet practices, hydration, and proper sleep are truly the foundations of wellness. An organic protein powder should be used as an extra boost of nutrients and protein, not as a substitute for healthy lifestyle habits.
We hope this post on our top 6 best organic protein powders has helped you decide which product is best for you. As well as providing important information on different nutrients and their benefits. We will do our best to continue to update this post on any new information on these products that becomes available to us.
Articles related to 6 Best Organic Protein Powders:
- Whey vs Plant Protein
- 24 Organic High Protein Foods
- Paleovalley Bone Broth Protein Review
- KaChava Superfood Review
- Cottage Cheese Nutrition Facts and 5 Amazing Benefits
See our high protein breakfast recipes:
References
Witkowska, Danuta et al. “Heavy Metals and Human Health: Possible Exposure Pathways and the Competition for Protein Binding Sites.” Molecules (Basel, Switzerland) vol. 26,19 6060. 7 Oct. 2021, doi:10.3390/molecules26196060. Accessed 1 Jan. 2024.
Paleovaley. “100% Grass Fed Bone Broth Protein.” Paleovalley, 2024, https://paleovalley.com/store/grass-fed-bone-broth-protein. Accessed 11 Jan. 2024.
Ka’Chava. “All In One Nutrition Shakes.” Ka’Chava, 2024, https://www.kachava.com/collections/all. Accessed 11 Jan. 2024.
Raw Organic Whey. “Raw Organic Whey.” Raw Organic Whey, 2024, https://www.raworganicwhey.com/products/raw-organic-whey-protein-5-lb-bulk#shopify-product-reviews. Accessed 11 Jan. 2024.
Just Ingredients. “Just Ingredients Plain Protein Powder.” Just Ingredients, 2024, https://justingredients.us/products/just-plain-protein-powder. Accessed 11 Jan. 2024.
Ora Organic. “So Lean & So Clean Plant-Based Superfood Protein.” Ora Organic, 2024, https://ora.organic/products/organic-protein-powder?variant=41705530065094. Accessed 11 Jan. 2024.
NorCal Organic. “Whey Protein.” NorCal Organic, 2024, https://norcal-organic.com/products/whey-1?variant=19705709575. Accessed 11 Jan. 2024.
Cleveland Clinic. “Collagen.” Cleveland Clinic, 23 May 2022, https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/articles/23089-collagen. Accessed 11 Jan. 2024.
Cleveland Clinic. “What Are Adaptogens and Are They Healthy?” Cleveland Clinic, 12 April 2022, https://health.clevelandclinic.org/what-are-adaptogens-and-what-do-they-do. Accessed 11 Jan. 2024.
Kuballa, Jillian. “Essential Amino Acids: Definition, Benefits, and Food Sources.” Healthline, 7 Aug. 2023, https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/essential-amino-acids#what-they-are. Accessed 11 Jan. 2024.
Stuart, Annie. “Branched-Chain Amino Acids.” WebMD, 18 Nov. 2022, https://www.webmd.com/vitamins-and-supplements/branched-chain-amino-acids-uses-risks. Accessed 11 Jan. 2024.
